As the founder of HadIt.com Veterans, I’ve seen many changes in how the VA approaches disability claims since 1991. The recent comments from the VA Secretary on veterans seeking increases in disability ratings deserve some thoughtful analysis.
What the Secretary Said
During an appearance on the Shawn Ryan show, the VA Secretary made statements that some veterans have interpreted as discouraging them from pursuing increased disability ratings. He suggested veterans focus more on improving their health rather than relying on “third-party helpers” in the claims process.
Understanding Third-Party Assistance
These “third-party helpers” include:
- C and P Examiners who conduct disability evaluations
- Claim consulting companies like Veterans Guardian and Veterans Claims Insider
- Veterans Service Organizations (VSOs) that provide free assistance
The Secretary appears to be encouraging veterans to take a more active role in both their health management and claims process, comparing it to learning to drive rather than hiring a driver.
The Health Improvement Focus
There’s merit in emphasizing health improvement for veterans. However, this creates a complex situation for many veterans whose conditions legitimately worsen over time. For example:
- A veteran with a service-connected knee injury might eventually need a replacement
- Mental health conditions like PTSD can deteriorate, requiring additional care and support
The System’s Inherent Tension
One challenge in the current system is that it can create conflicting incentives. Veterans are encouraged to improve their health, but doing so might risk benefits that provide crucial financial support and healthcare access. This is a systemic issue that needs addressing rather than placing the burden solely on veterans.
Finding Balance
Having worked with veterans navigating the claims process since 1991, I understand both sides of this discussion. Veterans deserve clear guidance about their benefits and support for health improvement. The system should recognize that seeking appropriate disability ratings and focusing on health improvement aren’t mutually exclusive goals.
Veterans have earned their benefits through service and sacrifice. The process should support them in accessing what they’ve earned while also providing pathways to better health outcomes when possible.
